Blog > Cap Rate and ROI in Kamuela, HI: What a $1M Rental Has to Earn
Buying an investment property in Kamuela, HI means making the math work in a market dominated by high-value single-family homes.
Key Takeaway
Run cap rate first to see what rent alone pays on a Kamuela home. Then run cash-on-cash return to see what your own money earns once the loan is in. At the single-family median, the standard rent-to-price rules of thumb set a monthly rent target few homes reach, so expect the income case to be thin. If rent alone doesn't carry the deal, the alternatives are a long hold built on appreciation or a property where short stays are legal. Either way, the slow pace of sales gives you room on the price that sets every return.
Who This Guide Is For
You're weighing a Kamuela investment property and need to work out whether its rent, loan, and Hawaii County costs add up to a return worth the asking price.
Why Cap Rate Is a Hard Test in Kamuela
Kamuela trades primarily as a single-family market, with those properties making up 14 of the 16 recent sales over a 90-day window. The median sale price for a single-family home here is $1,004,600. Because that figure rests on a sample of 14 sales, it points in a direction rather than locking in a trend.
Applying standard benchmarks to that median shows the income challenge quickly. The 1% rule says monthly rent should equal one percent of the purchase price, so a median-priced home would need about $10,046 a month. The 2% rule pushes that target to roughly $20,092 a month.
How to Calculate Cap Rate and ROI
How to Calculate Cap Rate
Cap rate measures a property's yearly yield assuming you pay in cash. Take a year of expected rent and subtract all operating costs to find your net operating income. Then divide that figure by the home's purchase price. The mortgage doesn't enter the equation.
That isolates the property's performance from your financing choices. The trade-off is that cap rate looks at one year of income and ignores both the loan and any price change. On a Kamuela house, it says nothing about your actual cash return or what a long hold might earn.
How to Calculate Cash-On-Cash Return and Total ROI
Cash-on-cash return measures what your down payment and closing costs earn after the bank gets paid. To find it, divide your annual cash flow after the mortgage by the total cash you put into the deal.
Total ROI adds the wealth built through loan paydown and property appreciation to that cash flow. Because it depends on an appreciation assumption, treat any projection as a scenario, not a forecast.
Hawaii County Costs That Set Your Net Operating Income
An accurate NOI for a Kamuela property has to include local expenses that most national calculators leave out.
Property Tax by Tax Class
Hawaii County taxes real estate based on its use class. For fiscal year 2026-2027, the rates per $1,000 of net taxable value are:
- Residential: $11.10, with higher tiered rates on value above $2 million
- Long Term Rental: $7.75
- Affordable Rental Housing: $5.75
Hawai'i County's home exemption reduces the taxable assessed value of an owner-occupied home and moves it into the lower Homeowner class at $5.75 per $1,000.
Look up the parcel's current assessed value and tax class with the County of Hawaii Real Property Tax Office. The seller's tax bill may reflect a homeowner exemption you won't qualify for, and underwriting with it overstates your net operating income.
General Excise Tax on Rental Income
Hawaii charges general excise tax on gross rent, not profit, so it cuts your NOI even in a year the property loses money. The County of Hawaii levies a 0.5% county surcharge, bringing the combined General Excise Tax rate on rental income in Hawaii County to 4.5%. The maximum amount that may be passed on to tenants, including the surcharge, is 4.7120%. If you host guests for under 30 days, short-term rental taxes add transient accommodations tax on top of GET.
Insurance, Hurricanes, and Lava Zones
Insurance costs depend on hurricane coverage and the parcel's location, so confirm the parcel's lava flow hazard zone and how your insurer prices it. Get a bound landlord insurance quote with hurricane coverage before your inspection contingency ends. Online estimates are not quotes, and underwriting without a bound quote can leave your NOI well short once you're under contract.
Property Management, Water, and Upkeep
Your operating costs should include water, sewer, vacancy allowances, and a repair reserve. The Hawaii County Department of Water Supply's rates took effect March 1, 2026. From July 1, 2026, the residential first-block consumption charge is $1.64 per 1,000 gallons. There is also a monthly standby charge based on meter size, such as $35.93 for a 5/8-inch meter.
Ask the seller for the last 12 months of actual operating costs. Get written quotes from at least two property managers for their fee and what it covers. Vacancy and repair reserves are estimates either way, and a seller's pro forma that leaves them out produces a cap rate the property won't earn.
Running the Numbers: A Long-Term Rental at the Kamuela Median Price
This example uses a home at the single-family median from the first section.
Step 1: Estimate Rent and Net Operating Income
Pull leased-rent comps for similar Kamuela and Waimea homes. If the home is tenanted, request the current lease and rent history. Relying on a projected figure or countywide benchmark instead can skew your entire calculation. Subtract every cost from the section above from your annual gross rent, and the result is your net operating income.
Step 2: Turn NOI into a Cap Rate
Divide your Step 1 net operating income by that median price to find the cap rate. You can also reverse the math to see what a target requires. Earning a 5% cap rate on that price means the property needs $50,230 of net operating income a year. Compare your projected NOI to that target to see quickly whether the rent can get there. This is the cash-only case, so read it alongside Step 3.
Step 3: Add the Loan for Cash-On-Cash Return
For illustration only, assume a 25% down payment of $251,150. As of October 29, 2026, Freddie Mac reported the 30-year fixed-rate mortgage average at 7.24%, though investment-property loans usually price higher. Ask your lender for the current investment rate and required down payment, then rerun this step with those numbers.
Subtract your annual debt service from your NOI, then divide the remainder by your $251,150 cash invested to find your cash-on-cash return. If the cap rate is below the loan's annual cost, each borrowed dollar earns less than it costs. In that case, cash-on-cash falls as you borrow more, and cash flow can turn negative.
Where the Return Comes from in Kamuela
When long-term rent alone produces a thin yield, the return has to come from appreciation over a long hold or from higher-grossing short stays.
Appreciation and Total Return
Kamuela's single-family median rose 10.4% year over year (based on 14 sales) in the 90 days ending September 30, 2026. A sample that small can make total ROI look artificially strong if you assume that pace will continue. Run your total return at several appreciation rates, including zero, to see which rate breaks the deal. A deal that only works if that pace repeats depends on appreciation, not income.
Short-Term Rental Income
Short-stay revenue is an option only where it's legally allowed. Check where short-term rentals are permitted and review current short-term rental regulations before counting any visitor revenue. If the home qualifies, weigh its short-term rental revenue and occupancy against the long-term rent from Step 1. Short stays also bring the transient accommodations tax noted above and higher management and furnishing costs, which lower your net operating income.
How the Kamuela Market Affects Your Purchase Price
The price you pay sets every return metric. Single-family homes recently took a median of 92 days to sell, with 6.2 months of supply, and sold at 98.3% of list price. All three figures rest on the same 14-sale sample.
On a market this slow, price is the one cap-rate input you can still change. Every point you negotiate off the asking price lifts the cap rate by about the same share of itself. Check the listing's days on market and price-change history before setting an offer.
How to Choose Which Return to Run First
If you're paying cash, cap rate is your return, so start with how to calculate cap rate and Step 2 of the example. If you're financing, go to Step 3 to test whether borrowing raises or lowers what you earn. If you don't know whether the property can legally host stays under 30 days, confirm that before counting any short-stay income, then read Short-term rental income. For a long hold, read Appreciation and total return. If the listing has sat past the median days on market, read How the Kamuela market affects your purchase price before you set an offer. When you're ready to evaluate a specific listing, reach out to a short-term rental investor agent to run the numbers.
At a Glance
- Single-family median sale price: $1,004,600 (based on 14 sales, 90 days ending 2026-09-30)
- All homes median sale price: $977,035 (based on 16 sales, 90 days ending 2026-09-30)
- Single-family median price change, year over year: +10.4% (based on 14 sales, 90 days ending 2026-09-30)
- All homes median price change, year over year: +8.3% (based on 16 sales, 90 days ending 2026-09-30)
- Single-family median price per square foot: $658 (based on 14 sales, 90 days ending 2026-09-30)
- All homes median price per square foot: $647 (based on 16 sales, 90 days ending 2026-09-30)
- Median days on market, single-family and all homes: 92 (based on 14 and 16 sales, 90 days ending 2026-09-30)
- Sale-to-list ratio, single-family and all homes: 98.3% (based on 14 and 16 sales, 90 days ending 2026-09-30)
- Share sold above list price: 14.3% single-family, 18.8% all homes (based on 14 and 16 sales, 90 days ending 2026-09-30)
- Months of supply: 6.2 single-family, 5.8 all homes (90 days ending 2026-09-30)
- Homes for sale: 29 single-family, 31 all homes (90 days ending 2026-09-30)
- Other property types (condos, townhomes, multi-unit): fewer than 10 sales in the window, so not reported
Kamuela Cap Rate and ROI FAQs
What Is the 7% Rule in Real Estate?
Definitions vary, but a common version says annual gross rent should be at least 7% of the purchase price. At the Kamuela single-family median (based on 14 sales), that means about $70,322 a year, or roughly $5,860 a month, before general excise tax and other operating costs.
What Is the Cap Rate If a Building Sells for $2,000,000 with an NOI of $150,000?
The cap rate is 7.5%: $150,000 of net operating income divided by the $2,000,000 price. The same cap rate on a Kamuela home at the single-family median (based on 14 sales) would require $75,345 of net operating income a year.
What Is a Good ROI on a Kamuela Rental Property?
There is no published Kamuela cap-rate benchmark, so a good return is one that beats your next-best use of the same cash after Hawaii County costs.
What Is Considered a Bad ROI on a Rental Property?
A bad return is a negative cash-on-cash return, where the property needs money from you each month. A yield below a lower-risk alternative also counts: the 10-Year Treasury par yield was 5.05% as of October 28, 2026.
Does Cap Rate Account for the Mortgage?
No. Cap rate uses net operating income before debt service, so the mortgage enters only your cash-on-cash return.
What Does a Higher Cap Rate Mean for ROI?
A higher cap rate raises your cash-on-cash return when it exceeds your loan's annual cost, and below that cost borrowing pulls the return down. Get a specific lender quote to see how borrowing affects your deal.
Does Cap Rate Determine Value for a Kamuela Home?
Not for a single-family home. Lenders' appraisals rely mainly on comparable sales. The income approach is required only for two- to four-unit properties, and an appraisal can't rely on it alone. In Kamuela the comparable-sale yardstick is the $658 single-family median price per square foot (based on 14 sales), so cap rate tells you whether that price works for your portfolio, not what an appraiser will say.
Is Kamuela the Same as Waimea?
Yes, Kamuela is the postal name for Waimea on Hawaii Island. Search listings, sales, and rental comps under both names so your comp set isn't cut in half.
Sources
- Redfin: Data Center
- Hawaii Property Tax: Hawaii County Tax Rates
- AARP Foundation: Hawaii Property Taxes
- Hawaii Department of Taxation: County Surcharge
- Hawaii County Department of Water Supply: Water Rate Brochure
- Freddie Mac: Primary Mortgage Market Survey
- Stock Market Watch: Bonds
- Fannie Mae: Cost and Income Approach to Value
Leave a Reply

Agent RS 83053
